When Oregon takes custody of a child, it steps into the role of parent. The law holds it to that role.
What DHS can be held liable for
Foster care abuse claims against DHS are negligence claims. The survivor must show that the agency owed a duty, breached it, and that the breach caused harm. Common theories include:
Negligent certification
DHS is required to screen and certify foster parents, including background checks, home studies, and reference checks. Certifying a foster parent with a known history of abuse, criminal conduct, mental health crises, or prior founded allegations is a frequent basis for liability. In the 2014 Multnomah County case that produced a $4.1 million verdict, the evidence showed DHS approved a foster mother despite a psychiatric hospitalization history and a prior firing for medical negligence.
Negligent placement
Even a properly certified home may be an unsafe placement for a particular child, for example placing a young child with a foster family already caring for a teenager with a documented history of sexual behavior, or exceeding the home's certified capacity.
Failure to investigate or act on reports
DHS operates the statewide child abuse hotline and is required to screen and assign reports. Cases where the hotline received multiple reports and did nothing are among the most valuable, because the agency's own records prove notice. The 2026 Multnomah County verdict of $29 million rested on a single hotline call that a screener neither forwarded nor documented.
Negligent supervision and monitoring
Caseworkers are required to make regular face-to-face contact with children in care, in private, and to document those visits. Missed visits, visits conducted in the presence of the foster parent, and visits that recorded injuries without follow-up all support liability.
Failure to provide services and medical care
The state must arrange medical, dental, and mental health care for children in its custody. Chronic failures in this area were central to the Wyatt B. class action settled in 2024.
The Oregon Tort Claims Act
Claims against the state are brought under the Oregon Tort Claims Act, ORS 30.260 to 30.300. Several features matter in foster care cases.
The state is the defendant, not the caseworker
Under ORS 30.265, when a state employee acts within the scope of employment, the claim is brought against the public body itself. Individual caseworkers are generally substituted out. This is a procedural point, not a limit on recovery.
Tort claim notice
Ordinarily, written notice of the claim must be given to the state within 180 days of the injury. However, ORS 30.275(8) removes that requirement for claims against DHS or the Oregon Youth Authority by a person who was under 18 and in the agency's custody when the conduct occurred. Most foster care abuse claims qualify. Claims by children who were not in state custody, and claims against private foster parents or agencies, are analyzed separately.
Damage caps
ORS 30.271 caps the damages recoverable from the state for a single claimant, with a higher aggregate cap per occurrence. The caps are adjusted annually for inflation by the Office of the State Court Administrator. Because of these caps, identifying private defendants who are not capped, such as contracted placement agencies and facility operators, is an important part of maximizing recovery. Large settlements like the $40 million Keizer case reflect multiple claimants and multiple occurrences.
No jury against the state in state court, but federal options
OTCA claims in Oregon circuit court are tried to a jury like other negligence claims. Many foster care abuse cases are also brought in federal court under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging that state actors violated the child's Fourteenth Amendment right to safety while in state custody. The $40 million Keizer settlement was reached in the U.S. District Court in Eugene. Federal constitutional claims are not subject to OTCA caps, but require proof of deliberate indifference rather than ordinary negligence.
What DHS records reveal, and how to get them
Foster care abuse cases are won or lost on paper. The state's own files usually contain the evidence. Relevant records include:
- The foster home certification file, including the home study, background checks, references, and any prior complaints or corrective action plans
- Hotline screening reports and CPS assessment records for every report involving the home or the child
- Caseworker contact notes, monthly visit logs, and supervisory reviews
- Placement history, including capacity at the time of placement and every other child in the home
- Medical, dental, and mental health records arranged (or not arranged) by the agency
- Juvenile court dependency file, including reports submitted to the court and any CASA reports
Former foster youth have a right to request their own case records from ODHS Child Welfare. Once litigation is anticipated, a preservation demand should be sent so that records are not purged under retention schedules.
Luke Stanton has read thousands of these files from the state's side.
As a Senior Assistant Attorney General from 2018 to 2022, he litigated dependency cases for Oregon's child welfare agency. He knows how the records are organized, which documents caseworkers are required to create, and where the gaps that signal negligence usually appear.
How the state defends these cases
The Oregon Department of Justice Trial Division defends DHS. Expect the state to argue that:
- The claim is time-barred, or that the survivor should have discovered the connection between abuse and injury earlier
- Caseworkers followed policy and had no notice of the specific risk
- The abuser's conduct was an unforeseeable intervening cause
- Damages should be capped, or apportioned to non-state defendants
- A parent or other caregiver shares the blame and should be added to the case
- In federal claims, that the conduct amounted to negligence at most, not deliberate indifference
Each of these has answers, and the answers come from the record. Building the record early is the single most important thing your attorney can do.
When the state tries to blame your family
For roughly a decade, state attorneys defending DHS sometimes filed third-party complaints against the parents of children who sued, including parents who had never been accused of harming the child. In a 2025 Multnomah County case, the state sued the mother of a teenager who had been sexually abused after DHS ignored hotline warnings. The jury cleared the mother and found DHS at fault.
After The Oregonian reported on the practice in November 2025, the Attorney General's office said trial attorneys had been told to stop using that approach without his approval. The tactic may still appear in some cases, and the shared-fault arguments behind it have not gone away. Knowing it is possible, and preparing for it from the start, protects both you and the people who stood by you.
Your family should not be afraid to support you.
If you are worried that bringing a claim could pull a parent or relative into the case, raise it in your first conversation. It is a known risk, and there are ways to plan for it.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue the caseworker personally?+
Under the Oregon Tort Claims Act, claims for conduct within the scope of employment are brought against the state, and the state is substituted for the employee. Federal civil rights claims under § 1983 can name individual employees, subject to qualified immunity.
Does it matter that DHS is now called ODHS Child Welfare?+
No. The agency has been reorganized and renamed over the years, but the State of Oregon is the responsible party regardless of the name the division used at the time.
I was placed through a private agency, not directly by DHS. Who do I sue?+
Often both. The private agency has its own duties and is not protected by the OTCA caps, while DHS retained legal custody and oversight. Naming both preserves all avenues of recovery.
Sources
- 1.ORS 30.260 to 30.300, Oregon Tort Claims Act
- 2.ORS 30.275, Notice of claim
- 3.The Oregonian/OregonLive, Nov. 12, 2025, state attorneys shifted blame to parents
- 4.OPB, Nov. 19, 2025, state lawyers blame parents in some negligence claims
- 5.ORS 30.271, Limitations on liability of state for personal injury and death
- 6.OPB, "Oregon's payouts for wrongdoing grow; threaten solvency of state insurance fund" (Feb. 19, 2025)
- 7.Disability Rights Oregon, Wyatt B. v. Kotek litigation resources
Updated September 2026. This page is general legal information and is not legal advice. Time limits and notice rules are fact-specific; contact an attorney about your situation.